I think there’s something to be gained from thinking outside the human box. It’s tough to do- everything we know is from the human perspective. At the very least, though, I think we can try to view our current society from an outsider perspective. It may provide some small insight into how extraterrestrials might view us if we ever make alien contact. By taking a critical view of our own society, essentially an outsider’s view, we might get a better indication of how an extraterrestrial civilization may view us.
I recently watched the movie “12 Years a Slave.” It is an unflinching view of American slavery that is in equal measures powerful and horrifying. The audience during my viewing, many of them African-American, gasped and cried out. A few folks even had to walk out during some of the more brutal scenes. Slavery is reviled in most segments of human society now. It still exists in some nations and underground on the black market. Still, much has changed in the last 150 years.
Every generation has something to regret: WW II atrocities for the Germans and Japanese, segregation, and apartheid, to name just a few. These, as with slavery, were supported widely throughout society at the time and ingrained institutionally. That begs the question: what do we support as a society currently that might be viewed negatively in future generations? Perhaps the inequitable treatment of women; homophobia; the poor treatment of animals; the use of environmentally damaging machines and technology; or our refusal to respond to global warming evidence? Clearly, this list is from my perspective. Your perspective could be very different. An extraterrestrial perspective would likely be very, very different. One would imagine that extraterrestrials would find many things flawed about our society. They may also see strengths that we might not even recognize as such.
Some of these concepts are easier for us to understand now than others. Environmental damage, while a matter of debate, is a concern for many on the planet. The treatment of animals interests me because it takes us out of the anthropocentric human perspective. Aliens could view dolphins and whales as equal with humans. We may be the dominate species, but that doesn’t mean aliens would necessarily side with us. The documentary "Blackfish" is a pointed message. The primary goal of the movie is to show how humans are doing animals a great injustice. It follows the SeaWorld capture and confinement of killer whales. I dare anyone to watch the documentary and not feel a sense of wrong when the whales are initially separated from their pod in the wild. What would aliens think of this? How would they view the slaughter of cows and pigs? Sure, this is just speculation, so you could argue that they might think such activities were great. I think there is value, though, in taking a critical look at who we are and what we do as a society, certainly for our own sake, but also to consider how outsiders might view us. It’s better to have pondered such things than to be blindsided if First Contact with extraterrestrials does occur someday.
What do you think? Join me on the Alien First Contact Facebook page.
Wednesday, February 12, 2014
Wednesday, January 29, 2014
Extraterrestrial Contact: The Argument Against Common Extraterrestrial Intelligence
Many of us are
excited by the planetary discoveries in other star systems that have become so
frequent recently, thanks to the hard work of dedicated researchers and some
amazing technology. These discoveries have led to an increasing number of
possibly habitable planets. Even more exciting- what about the chances of
intelligent life existing elsewhere in the universe? We would like to
extrapolate the number of possibly habitable planets to support an argument
that it increases the chances of intelligent life in the universe.
There are those who would like to throw cold water on this speculation and they often provide very good reasons for skepticism. One of the more interesting arguments recently ties a popular social theory to the search for extraterrestrial intelligence.
Dr. Michael West is the director of the Maria Mitchell Observatory in Massachusetts. He points out, in a recent USA Today column, that the Peter Principle might apply to the chances of extraterrestrial life occurring in the universe. The Peter Principle, as originally put forth by author Laurence Peter, says that humans rise to the level of their incompetence. If this is taken to an evolutionary level, could humans be at the apex of our competence and soon to fall due to our incompetence, in areas such as environment and warfare?
The danger of civilizations collapsing due to technology (or rather, a lack of control of technology) has been suggested for years. Given our dire set of circumstances (global warming and nuclear weaponry) it is quite possible that there is some sort of technology ceiling, that when reached, leads to catastrophic collapse of that civilization, and thus preventing the civilization from becoming more technologically advanced than humans.
This argument comes down to one big question: will humans be able to solve our current technological problems, create new technology to fix our mistakes and continue to move forward, perhaps one day turning into a space-faring civilization.
Human resilience is an amazing thing. Humans overcome all sorts of challenges in life. It’s something we notice individually and resilience can be seen on a larger level. Think how quickly Europe and Japan came back from the devastation of World War Two. Of course, there are many instances of civilizations disappearing, for one reason or another.
Does the Peter Principle imply that humans are headed for catastrophe? I suppose that will be up to future generations to decide.
Join me on the Alien First Contact Facebook page for more links and discussion.
Monday, January 13, 2014
Extraterrestrial First Contact: Science Pushes Us Forward
This blog is entirely speculation. I may refer to scientific research, but in the end it is just ideas and ideas are only a starting place. Science pushes and pulls us forward as a species. And it is science that is driving the study of possible extraterrestrial life and intelligence.
It is a much slower process
than many of us would hope. The funding is tough to come by, often requiring
private donations to sustain the work. Still, brave astrophysicists,
astronomers and astrobiologists are getting the work done. They risk professional
ridicule and the constant threat of de-funding.
Recently, astrobiologists testified before the U.S House Science Committee. They included Mary Voytek, the NASA Senior Scientist for Astrobiology, Sara Seager, professor of physics and planetary science at M.I.T., and Steven J. Dick, from the Library of Congress. They agreed on one important point: that life does exist elsewhere in the universe. News that members of Congress are at least willing to hear from scientists about the possibilities of extraterrestrial life is refreshing. Scientists at the SETI Institute in California are carrying out the search for possible intelligent life in the universe. Their work has encountered a number of funding issues over the years. It is Congress that cut the most significant funding in the search for extraterrestrial intelligence. It does not seem likely that Congress will restore that government funding any time soon.
Speculation and science fiction are important for engaging our imaginations. But it is science that will move us forward. If you believe in this effort, please support the scientists doing this work. Encourage proper funding for the important work of NASA. Consider a donation to the SETI Institute.
Join me on the Alien FirstContact Facebook page for more links and discussion.
Sunday, December 15, 2013
Extraterrestrial Contact: More Thoughts on Confusing First Contact
When it comes to extraterrestrial contact speculation there
is a disturbing middle ground between the negative First Contact scenarios of
alien invasion and the positive scenarios of a welcome into a larger universe.
First contact could leave us confused, full of questions and worried.
Confused: Aliens would likely be far different from us. They
may have an indecipherable language and an agenda that we could not understand.
Unless they were willing to teach us, First Contact could be one confusing set
of actions after another.
Full of questions: A lack of explanation about their
civilization and intentions would dash our hopes for First Contact. When we
speak of contact we are really talking about information. We hope that aliens
would teach us new things about the universe. If the aliens can’t communicate
or choose not to communicate, we could be left with only questions.
Worried: Any extraterrestrial civilization with the ability
for significant space travel would be a threat to humanity. Such ability would
show a higher level of technology than ours, and that would suggest that they
have the skills needed to build weaponry that we might not be able to match. If
we don’t know the intentions of the aliens we would be left with only the
possibility of threat.
SETI researchers often warn of this disturbing middle ground
in part because most things that humans experience are at first confusing and
worrisome. We would like life to be black and white, but as we well know, life
is seldom so. Our hopes for a warm and fuzzy First Contact experience and our
concern about alien invasion each seem rather unlikely. What is much more
likely would be a murky mess that may take years of study to unravel. And even
then, there may be very few definitive answers.
Can we handle such uncertainty? Would we spend our time and
money building space defenses? Would we become a more cynical society out of
constant worry? Perhaps the most important step in the maturity of the human
race is not some sweeping step into a wider universe, but merely the ability to
handle radical ambiguity? It’s not all sad. Such events could leave us even
stronger as a civilization in the long run and perhaps better able to handle
the next murky moment.
What do you think? Is this cynicism on my part or a strong
possibility should First Contact ever occur. Chime in on the Alien FirstContact Facebook page.
Monday, November 25, 2013
Extraterrestrial Contact: Knowledge Threshold
Intelligent aliens may or may not exist. They may be too far
away for us to contact. There are myriad possible reasons for why we haven’t
made First Contact. I offer one more: a knowledge threshold. What if aliens are
aware of the human civilization, but waiting until we reach a certain threshold
of scientific or cultural knowledge before they intend to make contact? This
isn’t an original thought on my part. It’s been the subject of many science
fiction stories.
What could that threshold be? Perhaps it is related to
physics. Humans are working hard to figure out what hypothetical dark matter
and dark energy might be. These postulates can be measured and even quantified,
in a sense, and yet there is still not an understanding of what they truly are
and of the relationship to our more common matter and energy.
The other big question in physics concerns particles. Work
with the Large Hadron Collider is attempting to advance human knowledge of
elementary particles, such as the Higgs boson. Perhaps this scientific inquiry
will lead us past the knowledge threshold? Aliens might be concerned that their
scientific knowledge is far in advance of ours. Perhaps we need to be at the
right level of knowledge to be able to handle further truths about our
universe?
The threshold could also be the biological-machine divide. Human
science is developing new machine devices to assist the human body. At some
point those devices could lead to bionic humans, at a point far beyond what we
experience now. Discoveries could also eventually lead to machine intelligence-
human intelligence housed completely in a machine. One could also call this
virtual life. These things seem like the stuff of science fiction, but they are
quickly becoming reality.
There could be another type of threshold: civilization
maturity. Let’s face it- humans are rather raw beings: we battle each other, we
kill, we tear up the natural environment and we treat other creatures on our
planet poorly. We still have a tense situation with nuclear weapons. We have a
long way to go in maturing as a human society. Perhaps aliens are simply
waiting for us to grow up?
The dangerous thing about threshold speculation is that it
is never-ending. We could use this as an excuse for why we haven’t made First
Contact and that could go on for however long we wanted. It may simply be
another human coping mechanism. I think many of us long for extraterrestrial
contact.
It’s easy to find comfort in excuses. I’ll put my trust in
the scientific process being carried out by the folks involved in the Search
for Extraterrestrial Intelligence, or SETI. I donate regularly to the SETI Institute, which has suffered setback after setback from budget cuts and
defunding. If you believe in the scientific effort to search for signs of
extraterrestrial intelligence please consider making a donation. Action is always
more powerful than speculation.
Thursday, October 24, 2013
Extraterrestrial Contact: Not Now, We’re Busy
Timing is everything, and as I have suggested before,
extraterrestrials who want to make contact with humans would be advised to
choose their moment carefully. One would imagine that it would be best to make
contact with humans who can properly focus on the challenges of First Contact
with an alien civilization. Distractions may seem like a minor point when it
comes to the enormity and significance of First Contact. But there have been
periods in human history during which aliens would want to avoid making
contact. Examples? How about during World War Two? You have many nations
involved in horrible conflict and technology developing that promises new ways
to kill people on a mass scale. As a visiting alien do you really want to step
into that? Nations involved in the conflict could hardly take the time to
properly handle such an interaction. Most likely, they would want nothing more
from the relationship than technology to better kill people on the other side
of their conflict.
Here’s another example: the Cold War. During the darkest
days of the Cold War the United States and the Soviet Union were on a
hair-trigger response to threat. A visiting extraterrestrial craft could
provoke a dangerous response. Paranoia would enter into the picture. Each side
could believe that extraterrestrials were a ploy on the part of the other.
These are extreme examples. Others may appear quite mundane
in comparison, and yet still provide a significant reason for aliens to stay
away. The latest would be the battle in the United States Congress over the
budget and the debt ceiling. At first blush this might seem like a national
issue. But in the larger scheme of things, the US Government defaulting on it’s
debt obligations would have a huge impact on world economic markets, both in
reality and perhaps more importantly, psychologically. Instability is a
dangerous thing, no matter how it comes about. Instability requires hard work
on the part of humans to solve specific challenges. Those efforts would make it
tough to respond to significant new challenges. Extraterrestrial First Contact
of any type would be a significant world challenge.
Now it would be easy to claim that all sorts of issues on
planet Earth are a reason for aliens to leave us alone. And one could then jump
to the conclusion that this could be the reason for the “Eerie Silence” as Paul
Davies has put it. But, as in all speculation, there is no evidence.
Intelligent aliens may be too far away to even realize we are here. Or they
just might not care to make contact. Or they may be waiting for us to make
contact.
If that changes, and some day extraterrestrials decide to
say hello, they might be well advised to keep an eye on the news of the day.
Sometimes humans just have too much on their collective plate to handle. And in
those moments it might be best to just leave us alone for a while until we can
get it sorted out.
Join me on the Alien First Contact Facebook page.
Tuesday, October 8, 2013
Extraterrestrial Contact: Human Exceptionalism
First contact with an extraterrestrial civilization raises a few questions about how we perceive ourselves as humans. Where goes anthropocentrism in the wake of extraterrestrial contact? Are we forced to challenge our belief that humans are superior to other creatures on Earth? How about our role in the wider universe?
Anthropocentrism is another way of expressing the idea of
exceptionalism. Exceptionalism is most often used these days in the American
context. American politicians refer to exceptionalism as a way to show the
American government and society as unique in history and something that other
nations should aspire too. Most recently, Vladimir Putin criticized the concept
of national exceptionalism in an op-ed in the New York Times, in reference to
planned American actions in Syria.
Human exceptionalism is understandable. Currently we stand
along in the universe, at least from our perspective. We dominate our planet in
many ways. We could, and often do, change the environment to suit our wishes.
If this has a detrimental impact on other species- oh, well, sorry, human needs
come first. There has been a backlash against such thinking. The discovery of a rare spider in Texas recently caused a $15 million highway project to come to a
screeching stop. Environmentalists across the globe are engaged in battles to
protect the habitats of other creatures. But if First Contact with an alien
civilization ever did occur would we be inviting dolphins or whales to share in
the experience? Would we bother to consult dogs? Laugh if you want, it’s our
anthropocentrism that drives the humor. Aliens wouldn’t necessarily think the
same way. They might not care about dogs or dolphins or they could care very
much, even taking the time to learn how to properly communicate with such
creatures.
It seems to me, though, that the biggest question of human
exceptionalism in the wake of high information First Contact is how we will
react. We can lord over cats and chimpanzees, but how about intelligent aliens?
If they could reach us, or communicate with us, they would likely be quite
intelligent, perhaps much more so than us. If that’s the case, where goes human
exceptionalism? Into the waste basket?
And perhaps that’s a concern for life forms considering a
visit to Earth. Will humans be threatened by visitors and react with violence?
It seems unlikely, but we have lots and lots of weapons. Anything could happen
if we’re scared enough.
This larger existential question is what interests me. Who
will we be, in our own minds, when we discover that there is at least one other
intelligent civilization out there? How will we place ourselves in this new
understanding of our universe? I think in some respects we might be better off
if it was revealed that there are dozens of civilizations out there. At least
in that case we would not automatically compare ourselves solely with our new
visitors. It might be easier being just another fish in the pond, than an
inferior fish to the only other fish in the known pond.
There is also the question of how aliens would view human
exceptionalism. We may very well hold our views even after other intelligent
civilizations are revealed. We could feel that the human way of life is
superior to the way of living for other intelligent beings. After all, many
Americans consider their country exceptional and there are plenty of other
countries on planet Earth. What ramifications would such a thing have on a long
term relationship with extraterrestrials? Would aliens consider that way of
thinking a threat? And then there is the flipside- alien exceptionalism. Would
they feel superior to us? Would they expect us to take on their
characteristics? That could be an extremely disturbing turn of events.
Most people would not worry about such things in the wake of
First Contact, and certainly not in the immediate, heady days of discovery.
However, I do think it’s an important topic for social scientists to consider, as
it could have profound implications for our long-term human development After
First Contact.
What do you think? Join the conversation on the Alien First Contact Facebook page.
Monday, September 23, 2013
Extraterrestrial Contact: The Challenge for Humanity
First Contact with an extraterrestrial civilization would be a major historical event and perhaps, depending on our level of interaction with aliens, a catalyst for paradigm shifts and revolutions across the spectrum of human sciences. There is no doubt that, in some degree, there would be a change in human perspective as a result of evidence that we are not alone. Once again, that degree would depend on the level of interaction with aliens and the type of information we receive. If it’s the discovery of a mysterious, far-off signal, First Contact would have less of an impact on human perspective than if we can actually converse in some way with aliens.
But those are the merely the passive results of First
Contact, the things that will change due to the nature of the information we
receive. What about the active endeavors? One could argue that changes in
science are not passive, in that they require a great deal of work on the part
of researchers and academics. My point is that reactions in science would be
reactions to new information. We would not necessarily be actively using the
situation to change things in our society. The information we receive about
aliens would undoubtedly change us, but we won’t necessarily control the
change.
Controlling the change is essential. The change will help to
decide the path for human development for generations to come. If we merely
react to the information we are given, we are not controlling the change.
Humanity needs to see First Contact, in any form it might take, as a challenge
that requires a much broader response and a response that would take well-considered,
proactive measures. We would need to perceive First Contact not as something
that is happening to us, but something that has happened, and that in turn we
are determining our course of action. It‘s a big difference.
First Contact provides possibility for the human race. It will give us a new perspective on our role
in the universe. It can also be a catalyst for change in the human
civilization. If we truly embrace the greater challenge, we could see First
Contact as a call for a larger discussion of what we want for human
civilization, in both the short-term and long-term. What kinds of things should
be discussed? Clearly, First Contact would require us to immediately consider
the nature of our world organizations- how nations interact and how we will
make decisions as a civilization. International relations are, at best, rather
muddled currently. If we find out that alien civilizations exist, the need for
some new form of organized discourse between nations, and ultimately better
methods of determining action, will be immediate. Other changes could include
better economic cooperation, global intervention in developing conflicts and global
support of human rights. In the wake of First Contact, humanity will have the
opportunity to finally take these issues seriously, on an international level,
above and beyond what is happening today in the United Nations and with
international diplomacy. First Contact could provide an impetus to action on a
new level.
Does First Contact necessarily mean humans will rethink
national interactions and come up with solutions to world problems? Of course
not- we could easily dissolve into disputes between nations under the pressure
of First Contact. It will take hard work and determination to make substantive
changes. First Contact would be an opportunity for an evaluation of our
civilization. It is an exciting opportunity to chart the course for generations
to come. And perhaps we shouldn’t wait around for aliens. Whether anyone else
is out there or not, we are one planet, one people- citizens of the universe.
What do you think? Join the conversation on the Alien FirstContact Facebook page.
Monday, September 9, 2013
Extraterrestrial Contact: Placing My Bet
Why do I waste my time contemplating extraterrestrial First Contact? There is no evidence that intelligent aliens exist. We may not have the proper technology to discover them ourselves. It could be decades, if not centuries, before First Contact occurs, if it ever does at all. Aliens could be so far away in the universe that we may never even know they are there, let alone make contact. Pretty depressing.
My thought is this: why not bet on the long shot? The odds are long;
incredibly long in this case, but the importance of the race cannot be
understated. Direct Contact with intelligent aliens would change our civilization.
Even long-term, far-away contact would change our perspective on the wider universe
and our own society. In a way, it’s a reverse payout. If First Contact does
occur, instead of there being some big prize for humanity there may be
incredible challenges. So, to not bet on the long shot, to not prepare for the
long shot, opens us up to danger. The lack of consideration and planning for
this subject is a real problem. If First Contact were to happen, human society
would not have a response. Hopefully, it will take years for us to transmit
back and forth with aliens, due to the distances between star systems. That
would provide plenty of time for the inevitable discussion, debate and action
to take place. But what if it is Direct First Contact, where aliens visit our
solar system to say hello? Such an event would leave us no time for planning
and little time to take action.
The big problem with considerations of extraterrestrial First Contact
is that everything is speculation. If it’s impossible to define what might
happen, how do you prepare for it? I would agree. Trying to plan details for a
First Contact response would be a waste of time. Our conjecture would likely be
wrong and thus a detailed plan not of much use. However, we could have a
general plan that answers a few important questions. First, who will represent
Earth if we make First Contact? I’m not talking about one person, but rather a
group. Which group will lead contact messaging? While scientists would be the
ones setting up the transmission it would seem logical that people who are
trained in diplomacy should decide the message, with plenty of input from
governments across the planet. Hmmmm… that sounds like the United Nations.
Indeed, SETI scientists have tried for many years now to have the United
Nations take First Contact seriously. Unfortunately, that has not happened. So,
there is a first step that could help in just about any First Contact scenario.
Perhaps the United Nations could allow the Committee on the Peaceful Uses of
Outer Space to take up the issue and develop some basic protocol.
What would be the reaction to such planning? Undoubtedly there would be
snickering in the media, and as UN officials probably fear, ridicule of the UN
and its mission. From the UN perspective reputation is everything. And if
you’re trying to handle civil war in Syria, prevent starvation in Africa and
join nations together in environmental causes, why would you jeopardize your
reputation for something that may never occur? It’s a very practical point of
view. And in a sense, it’s just another bet. The UN folks are betting that
First Contact will not occur and putting their entire wager on our current
human challenges.
I get this. I even understand the snickering of the media. We haven’t
taken issues of extraterrestrial intelligence seriously in our popular culture.
What makes us think that we will take it seriously in the realm of
international relations? Action by the UN will take guts and determination. It
will take courage and vision.
So, why do I waste my time on what some might call a childish pursuit?
Well, I actually agree that it is a childish pursuit. What child doesn’t
wonder, at some point or another, about what might be out there in the
universe? Those people often grow up to be astrophysicists or science fiction
writers. We can’t lose the childish wonder that fuels our passion to discover
new things. I’ll keep embracing that wonder as I continue writing for this
blog. It’s a high stakes race, if the race is ever run. I’ll keep betting on
the long shot and perhaps someday the UN and governments may put down their own
small wager as well.
What do you think? Are we wasting our time contemplating
First Contact? Join the conversation on the Alien First Contact Facebook page.
Monday, August 26, 2013
Extraterrestrial Contact: Would machines be inherently more adaptive?
If an extraterrestrial civilization designed intelligent machines to roam the universe those machines would likely have an important characteristic: the ability to adapt. Learning is part of intelligence. The ability to adapt would be combined with the learning process for active endeavors to overcome challenges and respond to new problems as they occur.
Machine extraterrestrial intelligence is a topic worth pursuing. Considering that humans send probes into
space to explore, it seems possible that extraterrestrial civilizations might
do the same. Paul Davies and Seth Shostak have talked about this idea for years
now.
There would be possible benefits and many issues in such an
extraterrestrial First Contact.
What would the adaptability of intelligent machines mean for us? It
could take away many of the barriers in terms of communication and cultural
understanding if extraterrestrial machines were to visit our solar system. Why?
If they wished to make contact, they would learn and adapt to do so. An
intelligent machine wanting to make contact would likely spend some time
learning about us- our languages, our cultures and our technology. This would
make sense for any intelligent extraterrestrial visitor. It’s probably what we
would do if we discovered an extraterrestrial civilization in our travels.
There would not be much to gain by charging in without knowing languages or
understanding the cultures of the beings on the planet you wished to contact. Alien
machines would want to learn human languages, they would be interested in how
we might react and, perhaps most importantly, they would have a game plan, a
process for undertaking an introduction.
Could alien machines be better able to adapt than biological visitors?
They probably wouldn’t be hung up with the prejudice of biology and culture,
perhaps making them less judgmental and more open to other ways of being. However,
their programming and base intelligence would probably be very different from
ours. Sorting that out could be difficult for us. Also, our conception of
machine intelligence might be very different from the type of advanced
technology we might encounter. Our machines serve us. Alien machines could be
self aware and have their own agenda, different over time even from their
creators.
There is certainly plenty of fun science fiction on this topic. And all
of this imaginative speculation would have positive and negative impacts if a
real situation was to develop some day. There could be fear of machines on our
part, thanks to the Terminator movies, the TV show Battlestar Galactica and
other popular fiction that features computers taking over the world. This alone
would force adaptive alien machines to consider human public relations and
carefully study how we interact and how we would best respond.
It all comes back to motives. Intelligent machines, just like
biological extraterrestrials, would have a reason for coming to our solar
system. Perhaps they are designed to explore, much like our probes? Perhaps
they are designed to make contact? We could hope that would be the case,
because then the need to understand human culture could be built into the
machine programming. Any help we could get in First Contact would be a good
thing. If the machines were not designed to adapt or even care about human
interaction it could be a mysterious alien encounter that we would never fully
understand. And that could be the most frustrating scenario of all.
What do you think? Join the conversation on the Alien FirstContact Facebook page.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)